In the section of reasoning there is major influence towards
syllogism part in many examinations. This part can be solved using two methods: Venn diagram and
Analytical Method.
One needs to follow these simple steps to solve a problem by
using analytical method.
Step 1: Alignment
of the sentences. As we know there must be one term in common so we should
align in such a way that we can at least draw a conclusion from them.
For example: i. All A are B. ii. Some A are C.
These sentences can be aligned in two ways.
a. All A are B means Some B are A. Hence our aligned pair is Some B are A and Some A are C.
b. Some A are C means Some C are A. Hence the aligned pair is Some C are A and All A are B.
These sentences can be aligned in two ways.
a. All A are B means Some B are A. Hence our aligned pair is Some B are A and Some A are C.
b. Some A are C means Some C are A. Hence the aligned pair is Some C are A and All A are B.
Step 2: Use of
Table to determine conclusion.
Before this you all should know about the coding that is
used for syllogism. For example, we have 4 sets of statements,
a. All A are B. (Coded as A)
b. No A are B. (Coded as E)
c. Some A are B. (Coded as I)
d. Some A are not B. (Coded as O)
a. All A are B. (Coded as A)
b. No A are B. (Coded as E)
c. Some A are B. (Coded as I)
d. Some A are not B. (Coded as O)
From these sentences a total of 13 possibility can be drawn
out of which in 6 possibilty can have conclusions. They are:
First statement
|
Second Statement
|
Conclusion
|
A
|
A
|
A
|
A
|
E
|
E
|
E
|
A
|
O*
|
E
|
I
|
O*
|
I
|
A
|
I
|
I
|
E
|
O
|
In all the conclusions the subject is the subject of the
first statement and predicate is the predicate of the second statement. However
in case of O*, the subject is the
predicate of the second statement and the predicate is the subject of first
statement.
Step 3: Immediate
conclusions might be there and one must look into it first. For example,
Statement a. All A are B. b. All B are C.
Conclusion b. All A are C. b. Some C are A.
The conclusion is clearly A+A=A i.e. All A are C. But if we convert the conclusion then we can find Some C are A. Hence both the conclusion follows.
Statement a. All A are B. b. All B are C.
Conclusion b. All A are C. b. Some C are A.
The conclusion is clearly A+A=A i.e. All A are C. But if we convert the conclusion then we can find Some C are A. Hence both the conclusion follows.
Step 4: Complementary Pairs.
Statements are said to be complementary if, firstly, both of
them have same subject and predicate and secondly, they are an I/O, A/O, I/E
pair. In a complementary pair one of the two conclusions is bound to be true.
This was a quick recap of how to solve syllogism using
analytical method.
No comments:
Post a Comment